Dogs are natural chewers and we are exploring Elk Antlers as an option for your dog chew.   Whether it’s a puppy exploring his new world through his mouth, or adult dogs chewing to release pent-up energy and/or stress, most dogs enjoy this instinctive behavior.   While almost anything is better than your K9 destroying your expensive leather shoes or couch to indulge their need to chew, are all chew treats created equal (and safe)?

Aggressive Chewer


Are All Chews Created Equal?

After the shocking revelation in 2007 about the toxic, Chinese-made dog treats sickening and even killing pets (dogs and cats); dog owners everywhere became more concerned and vigilant about the treats they were offering to their dogs.

When even more information came out about all the potentially deadly chemicals used to mass-produce rawhide in China, “safe” choices became even further limited for canine guardians. (Not to mention numerous horror studies about rawhide pieces becoming stuck or causing obstructions requiring surgery to save a dog.) Click here to learn the harmful truth behind making rawhide.

Chewing Elk Antler

Are Elk Antlers a Safer Option?

So, what about something more “natural,” like antlers from wild deer or elk?

The first thing to point out is that there is a difference between a deer and an elk antler. In relevance to dog chews, the difference lie in the hardness and sponginess of the antlers. Deer antlers are the hardest and the most likely to cause dental-related injuries. It is also important to note that deer antlers are the easiest and most common antlers harvested, making up perhaps the largest bulk of antlers available for sale.

While Moose and Mule Deer antlers have their merits as safe dog chews, Elk Antlers are among the more readily available, safe dog chews. Elk Antlers split down the center allow less aggressive chewers easier access to the marrow. However, when buying split antlers, it is important to understand that they will not last as long as a whole antler for dogs the DO chew aggressively.

Like most subjects about dog health, “expert” opinions about whether antlers are a completely safe chewing option falls between both ends of the spectrum. From slick marketing campaigns raving about the wonders of antlers for your dog’s chewing pleasure to so-called dog experts decrying even the thought of offering an antler to your dog to chew. While the controversy rages on, educate yourself on the pros and cons of antler chews for your dog.

Factors to Consider Before Offering an Elk Antler

Deciding whether an antler chew is good (or not) for your dog involves a number of factors, including:

• What kind of chewer your dog is;
• Your dog’s current dental health;
• The “grade” of antler you are planning to give your dog to chew; and
• The supplier/distributor of the elk antlers and whether they sell cheaper, low-grade or inferior products.

When you know better, you can make better choices for what to safely offer your dog to chew. Knowing your own dog is the first place to start. Is your dog a heavy or aggressive chewer? The chewing needs or habits are vastly different for a Chihuahua versus a Rottweiler. Smaller teeth and jaws require a smaller or softer chew.  Also, consider your dog’s current dental health. Have they suffered from dental issues that would rule out giving them hard items to chew?

• Loose teeth?
• Teeth factures or breakages? (According to Embrace Insurance Company, up to 20% of dogs will suffer a fractured tooth.)
• Symptoms of gum disease like receding gums, bone loss, gingivitis and periodontitis? Gum disease can make teeth unstable and incapable of standing up to chewing. (Did you know that gum disease, is five times more common in dogs than in humans?)

Not sure if your dog’s teeth are healthy? Click here to learn more.

If you have determined your dog’s dental health and chewing needs include hard chewing, keep reading to learn more about elk antler chews.

What is an Antler?

Antlers come from moose, caribou, elk, reindeer and deer. Typically, elk antlers are the easiest ones to find. Antlers that are processed and graded correctly do not splinter or chip as easily as cooked bones or some other chew toys. While antlers may seem similar to “horns” … they are actually quite different. Cow horns are made from a substance called keratin; similar to our nails and hair. They also have a lining of bone inside them.

Antlers, on the other hand, are made from real bone and cartilage with a marrow core. They are actually a bony outgrowth of the animal’s skull. Since they are actual bone, they are also very hard. Antlers are typically shed each year allowing a new set to grow in their place. Antlers (unlike processed bones or rawhides) also offer nutritional value in the form of:

• Calcium
• Protein
• Chondroitin Sulfate
• Glucosamine
• Collagen
• Magnesium
• Iron and Zinc

For raw-fed dogs, bones are important to their diet. But, it is not necessary for them to eat very hard bones (like antlers or weight-bearing leg bones).

Grading Elk Antlers and What it Means

Antlers are “graded” on five different levels. Before you buy any kind of antler for your dog to chew, below is what you need to know first.

Grade A+ Elk Antlers

These are the highest quality and most pristine antlers, previously reserved for high-end craft and artisan use. They constitute less than 5% of all antlers each year. Only a few stores and distributors are focused on selling antlers of this caliber.

Grade A Elk Antlers

These antlers comprise the top 10-15% of all antlers each year. They have been shed during the current – or previous – year. These antlers will appear a little more on the light-brown side; as they have been freshly shed and have had only minimal exposure to the elements.

Grade B Elk Antlers

This grade of antler comprises the bulk of all antlers sold online by the “high-end” brands. These antlers are easily recognized as they will be white from sun bleaching which also means they are dried out. They may also show visible marks of rodent chewing. These antlers are approximately one to two years old. While they may be sold by well-established brands, it does not mean they are “safe dog chews.” While they are not the worst of the antlers, they are definitely not the safest for your dog based on their age and being dried out which means they could splinter or chip much more easily.

Grades C and D Elk Antlers

The final two grades are combined together because, for all intents and purposes, these antlers are “junk” and definitely not safe for your dog. These antlers are not only white from years in the sun and exposure to the elements; but there is also a white powder that can be easily scraped off the surface. In addition, the antler has almost a coral-like porous crystalline structure to it, due to having lost too much moisture. This makes it even more susceptible to breaking, splintering or chipping even with minimal effort. These antlers are commonly sold in the big-box pet stores and even in outdoor sports stores.

A Few Cautions

• Make sure any antler product you buy and give to your dog is sourced from the USA (preferably from organically-raised animals). Note: China does chemically process and ship antlers to the United States.
• Also, make sure you buy the right size antler for your dog (one that cannot be easily swallowed).
• And finally, no chew product is 100% safe and healthy for every dog. Digestive or dental issues, possible choking (in the mouth or throat) and intestinal obstructions are always a risk.
• Check with your veterinarian first before giving your dog any chew product.

In Conclusion

At Country Comfort Boarding & Grooming, we offer Grade A and A+ Elk Antlers in our treat store, but not any other kind of antler.  The antlers are among other chews we offer as different chews are appropriate for different dogs.  Just like our children, it is our responsibility to choose the appropriate dog chew, or toy in our children’s case, that is safe and satisfies their instinctual need to chew and clean their teeth.

Click for more information about Country Comfort boarding, grooming and doggie daycare.

Additional Resources

The Perils of Gum Disease in Dogs

Dogs Love These Chews, But They Fracture Teeth Like Crazy

Antlers for Dogs 101|Chews Wisely

Are Deer Antlers Safe for Dogs to Chew On?

Antlers for Dogs: Are Deer Antlers Safe for Dogs to Chew On?

Are Antlers Safe for Dogs?

Deer Antlers as a Chew Toy for Dogs

Are Deer Antlers for Dogs a Good Chew Toy?